Photo rating tool: upload a profile or dating photo and real people vote to score it on dimensions such as "smart, trustworthy, attractive", helping users pick photos.
In 2013 Ben Peterson and Ann Pierce in Boulder built a site where strangers anonymously rate your profile photo. At first it covered only professional headshots (LinkedIn), positioned as a "free headshot test tool + research project". The core mechanism is mutual rating: you vote on others' photos to earn credits, and credits buy ratings of your own photos, so the more users there are the faster results come, and anyone who does not want to wait pays for credits. Growth came from "data research as PR": they wrote studies from tens of thousands to hundreds of millions of ratings on the platform (in 2014, 60,000 ratings analyzing 800 professional photos; in 2017, a rebuttal of OKCupid's dating photo study; in 2019, a paper on an AI trained on 100 million ratings), got picked up by Business Insider, The Muse and other media, and asked those who republished to link back. In 2015 it added dating and social categories, catching Tinder and OKCupid users asking "which photo is the most attractive", and Reddit dating subs and looks-obsessed communities (looksmax) have discussed it for years, until the brand name became shorthand for "photo rating".One-line growth story, compiled by us from public sources; speculation is marked separately below.
The main engine is the peer-rating loop: you must vote on other people's photos to earn credits before you can test your own for free, and the more users there are the faster results come; direct visits are 60% and paid ads are almost 0.
The turbo boost is data-research PR: research written from ratings on the platform was republished by media such as Business Insider, and the brand name became shorthand for "photo rating" on Reddit dating boards.
By estimate, over half of visits are returning users coming back to vote and test new photos; about 1.7 of every 100 visits click through to the checkout page.
Model: Lenny's racing growth framework. Engine = peer-rating loop (you must vote on others to test your own photos for free, the more users the faster results come, and users bring in newcomers by posting scores on Reddit and forums); turbo boost = data-research PR (headshot research, rebutting OKCupid, and the D3 paper republished by media); long-tail SEO is a supplement.
Real data: 756,800 visits, -36.61% month over month, the largest channel direct at 60.01%, the top-three channel ranking (direct, organic search, organic social), search split 99.77% organic and 0.23% paid, 701 search terms, top search terms (photofeeler, photo feeler, websites where women rate men, photofelr, youtube profile picture size), social sources (Reddit, YouTube, X), countries (US 21.5%, Germany 17.66%, UK 14.99%, Israel 7.64%, Brazil 5.1%), bounce rate 31.18%, 7.04 pages per visit, and an average stay of 5 minutes 58 seconds come from the Similarweb public page for last month; the public page does not give the shares of the second and third channels. The 12,894 visits (about 12,900) to the Stripe checkout page come from the quietmoney checkout page data. Semrush's desktop source split (direct 80.8%, search 17.8%, AI 0.7%, social 0.7%) is only used to judge that the second circle has a lot of search and little social, and is not treated as the site's true share.
Supporting evidence: Made in 2013 by Ben Peterson and Ann Pierce of Boulder, at first only testing professional headshots; in 2014 a professional photo study written from over 60,000 ratings was covered by Business Insider and The Muse; in 2015 dating and social categories were added; in 2019 the D3 model trained on 100 million ratings was released; the r/Tinder and looksmax forums have discussed for years whether it is accurate; competitors keep writing "Photofeeler reviews and alternatives".
Inference: The two channel circles are real, and how each route splits is an inference: direct 454,200 = returning users 360,000 + forum score posts 50,000 + media and review articles 44,200; other channels 302,600 = searching the name after media and reviews 102,600 + forum score posts 100,000 + returning users searching the brand name 70,000 + long-tail search 30,000. In the profile about 91.5% of search is branded keywords, so long-tail search only gets 30,000. The visit rates of 10% after seeing forum score posts, 5% after seeing media reviews, and 10% click-through after finding the blog are guesses.
Checkout: checkout.stripe.com
“Share buttons are only for the site itself ('Friends need better photos? Share on:'); reciprocal 'Vote on photos for a free test' is a contribution loop, not in”Quote from the site
New-user source: SEO (Non-brand search). Direct 80.8%, search 17.8% mostly brand keywords (brand keywords 91.5%), with non-brand long tail such as "websites where women rate men" and "youtube profile picture size"; AI referrals 0.7% (Gemini, ChatGPT). Social is Reddit, YouTube and X. Returning users come back to vote on others' photos to earn credits and to test new photos.
Semrush source breakdown (desktop)
| Attributable new users, last month | Share |
|---|---|
| SEO | 7% |
| GEO | 1% |
| 1% | |
| Other | 92% |
Direct + brand search 92%. Direct and brand search count as viral only when the site shows sharing mechanics; the largest share wins, under 5% means Other.
| Country | Share of visits |
|---|---|
| United States | 21.5% |
| Germany | 17.66% |
| United Kingdom | 14.99% |
| Israel | 7.64% |
| Brazil | 5.1% |
Countries (Semrush): Canada 26.1%, Germany 19.5%, Brazil 10.7%, United States 8.8%, France 5.5%
English
Reddit, YouTube, X (Twitter)
| Source | Share |
|---|---|
| Gemini | 0.19 |
| ChatGPT | 0.13 |
| toolify.ai | 0.01 |
AI referrals (Semrush): Gemini 781 (0.19%), ChatGPT 527 (0.13%), toolify.ai 19 (0.01%)
701 keywords · brand ~92% · organic 99.77% / paid 0.23%
| Similarweb top 5 keywords |
|---|
| photofeeler |
| photo feeler |
| websites where women rate men |
| photofelr |
| youtube profile picture size |
Non-brand queries: websites where women rate men, youtube profile picture size
| Category | Share of referrals |
|---|---|
| Graphics Multimedia and Web Design | 0.16% |
| Search Engines | 0.01% |
About 12,894 last month (Similarweb estimate), #276 of 606; the month before was 13,515. Opening checkout is not paying, so this is not revenue.
New-user source: SEO (Non-brand search). New users mostly come from need-based searches Direct 80.8%, search 17.8% mostly brand keywords (brand keywords 91.5%), with non-brand long tail such as "websites where women rate men" and "youtube profile picture size"; AI referrals 0.7% (Gemini, ChatGPT). Social is Reddit, YouTube and X. Returning users come back to vote on others' photos to earn credits and to test new photos.
Free (vote on others' photos to earn credits for your own ratings); $9 one-time for 40 credits, $19 for 100 credits (later tiers truncated in the input)
Dossier confidence: medium. Parts 1 and 2 come from reading the site and Similarweb data; part 3 from public reporting, founder posts, Wayback snapshots, WHOIS and similar, with speculation marked.
The number: checkout visits is Similarweb's estimate of visits from the site to a checkout payment page; opening checkout is not paying, so this is not revenue. Small sites land on fixed buckets.
Data through last month. Page updated 2026-10-31.