A personal soccer analysis newsletter on Ghost by MLS pundit Matt Doyle, writing on tactics and power rankings for MLS and the US men's national team, with some articles for members only.
Matt Doyle spent 15 years as the "Armchair Analyst" at MLSsoccer.com, and his signature column, the weekly MLS Power Rankings, is known to everyone in the MLS fan community. In 2024-12, sensing his job might go, he first opened a free Substack to gather his content from all over and build his Twitter/BlueSky readers into an email list; after MLS laid him off in 2026-02, he took that list to Ghost and opened paid memberships, moving the work he did for 15 years at MLS "back to his own house as is." The free Power Rankings and weekly roundup are posted to Reddit and X each week to attract new readers, while the paywall sits on the Sunday recaps, in-depth features and the monthly live AMA.One-line growth story, compiled by us from public sources; speculation is marked separately below.
The main engine is the author's personal brand and social distribution: Matt Doyle spent 15 years as an analyst at MLSsoccer.com and moved his whole email list over, and the free Power Rankings go out to Reddit and X every week to win new readers.
The lubricant is a fixed weekly schedule and email: free rankings on Monday and Tuesday, paid Sunday recaps and Wednesday features, and the email pulls subscribers back every week.
By estimate, about half of visits come from people who saw an article on Reddit or X, and 30% are returning readers; about 6 in every 100 visits click through to the checkout page.
Model: Lenny's racecar growth framework. Engine = the author's personal brand and social distribution (long-time readers from a 15-year MLS analyst career followed him, and the free Power Rankings are posted on Reddit and X every week); lubricant = a fixed weekly schedule and email that pulls subscribers back each week, with the paywall placed on the Sunday recap, Wednesday features and the monthly live AMA.
Real data: 137,400 visits, +16.61% month over month, largest channel direct at 44.17%, top-three channel ranking (direct, organic social, organic search), organic search 100% of search, 18 search terms in total, top search terms (usmnt fall camp, best supported mls teams in 2026, best usmnt prospects, best mls team, mls power rankings), social sources (Reddit, X), countries (US 93.87%, Mexico 2.62%, Australia 1.85%, South Africa 1.66%), bounce rate 48.61%, 1.71 pages per visit, average time on site 1 minute 30 seconds, all from the Similarweb public page for last month; the shares of the second and third channels are not given on the public page. 8,596 visits (about 8,600) to Stripe checkout pages are from quietmoney checkout page data.
Supporting evidence: Matt Doyle spent about 15 years as the Armchair Analyst at MLSsoccer.com, with the weekly MLS power rankings as his signature column. In 2024 he opened a free Substack to collect his content, and at the one-year mark said the subscriber curve was up and to the right. In early 2026 MLS laid him off, and he moved the old Substack posts and the email list to Ghost, opened three paid membership tiers, and joined Kickback Soccer Media. The Ghost site now has about 200 articles, 3-4 per week. The profile records social at 41.9% and search at 8.4%, which is an earlier basis and is not treated as the real shares here.
Inference: The two channel circles are real; how each route is split is an inference: direct 60,700 = email subscribers and returning readers 40,000 + clicking links in the X app 12,000 + podcast listeners 8,700; other channels 76,700 = clicking links on Reddit and X 56,000 + searching match topics 12,000 + podcast listeners 5,700 + returning readers searching for articles 3,000. Organic social is second, so it gets the most among the other channels. The ratios of 5% clicking through after seeing the rankings and articles, 10% after seeing search results, and 10% visiting after hearing the podcast are guesses.
Checkout: checkout.stripe.com
“Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only articles; Tip Jar”Quote from the site
New-user source: Social media (Organic social). Direct 44.2%, social 41.9% (Reddit, X), search 8.4% (mls power rankings, best usmnt prospects, etc.). New readers mainly arrive from Reddit fan forums and shares on X, and returning readers subscribe and come straight back to see each round's rankings.
Top channel measured by Similarweb, others estimated by rank
| Attributable new users, last month | Share |
|---|---|
| SEO | 8% |
| 42% | |
| Other | 50% |
Direct + brand search 44%. Direct and brand search count as viral only when the site shows sharing mechanics; the largest share wins, under 5% means Other.
| Country | Share of visits |
|---|---|
| United States | 93.87% |
| Mexico | 2.62% |
| Australia | 1.85% |
| South Africa | 1.66% |
English
Reddit, X (Twitter)
18 keywords · brand ~44% · organic 100% / paid 0%
| Similarweb top 5 keywords |
|---|
| usmnt fall camp |
| best supported mls teams in 2026 |
| best usmnt prospects |
| best mls team |
| mls power rankings |
Non-brand queries: usmnt fall camp, best supported mls teams in 2026, best usmnt prospects, best mls team, mls power rankings
| Category | Share of referrals |
|---|---|
| Sports - Other | 98.39% |
| News & Media Publishers | 0.17% |
About 8,596 last month (Similarweb estimate), #359 of 606; the month before was 207. Opening checkout is not paying, so this is not revenue.
New-user source: Social media (Organic social). New users mostly come from YouTube, X, Reddit, TikTok and the like Direct 44.2%, social 41.9% (Reddit, X), search 8.4% (mls power rankings, best usmnt prospects, etc.). New readers mainly arrive from Reddit fan forums and shares on X, and returning readers subscribe and come straight back to see each round's rankings.
Has members-only articles and a Tip Jar; prices not shown on the page
Dossier confidence: medium. Parts 1 and 2 come from reading the site and Similarweb data; part 3 from public reporting, founder posts, Wayback snapshots, WHOIS and similar, with speculation marked.
The number: checkout visits is Similarweb's estimate of visits from the site to a checkout payment page; opening checkout is not paying, so this is not revenue. Small sites land on fixed buckets.
Data through last month. Page updated 2026-10-31.